Employee or Independent Contractor?

Economic factors in recent years have led many businesses of all types and sizes to focus on building a contingent workforce rather than an employee base.  While this helps relieve financial hardships for many individuals and companies, it may also lead to some confusion regarding a particular individual’s role within a company.  If a worker fails to understand the difference, they may be unaware of the laws and taxes that apply to them.  This can lead to serious consequences with the IRS and other government labor agencies for both businesses and workers.


Benefits of Independent Contractors to Employers

It’s common knowledge that employees pay a certain percentage of their income in taxes.  However, in addition to the income tax, independent contractors are also required to cover their own payroll taxes.  This is the tax that businesses must pay on behalf of each employee (in addition to those employees’ income taxes).  In fact, it is also the tax that has led to an influx of independent contractors.  By building a contingent workforce, employers avoid their share of the payroll tax, thereby decreasing their operational costs without lowering their overall workforce.  However, it also means that workers will have to pay taxes at the end of the year rather than filing for a return.


Costs of Being an Independent Contractor

Why would the worker owe taxes at the end of the year rather than breaking even?  In addition to accepting responsibility for their own payroll taxes, independent contractors do not have taxes withheld from their paychecks (since they are considered to be their own bosses).  Regardless of how much money a contractor receives from their client, taxes are not withheld since they are not employees.  Therefore, in addition to paying the full bill for payroll taxes, contractors must also cover the state and federal withholding, social security and other taxes.  This leads most of them to pay their taxes quarterly rather than annually.

Independent contractors are also usually responsible for purchasing the tools and materials necessary for their work.  Clients may provide some of the necessary equipment, but it won’t typically be enough to complete the job’s full functions.  They are also responsible for maintaining their own inventory levels and ensuring that the right supplies are replenished when necessary.  Fortunately, they are also eligible for tax credits on virtually all business related purchases.  This can include paper, computers and even vehicle mileage.


Benefits For Being an Independent Contractor

While these expenses may lower the desire to become an independent contractor rather than an employee, the transition is not without its benefits.  Unlike employees, contractors are not subject to the 40 hour work week; they are free to garner as many hours and projects as they want without some boss chastising them for it.  They also determine their own pay and may change it for different projects based on the required effort.

Independent contractors also enjoy a greater level of independence.  While they may be required to follow the client’s outline, they are usually free to perform the work as they see fit.  Whether that means rebuilding an industrial machine within their air conditioned workshop or typing away in their pajamas at home, contractors are in control of their work and environment, unlike employees.


Tax Law Relating To Independent Contractors

It’s important to note what the IRS considers the criteria to be an independent contractor.  There is no “magic” formula according to the IRS, but here are the factors that must be considered:

  • Behavior: Does the company control or have the right to control what the worker does and how the worker does his or her job?
  • Financial: Are the business aspects of the worker’s job controlled by the payer? (these include things like how worker is paid, whether expenses are reimbursed, who provides tools/supplies, etc.)
  • Relationship: Are there written contracts or employee type benefits (i.e. pension plan, insurance, vacation pay, etc.)? Will the relationship continue and is the work performed a key aspect of the business?

Basically, if the answer is no to the questions above, the worker can be considered an independent contractor.  If you have some “Yes” answers, you probably want to consult a tax attorney prior to classifying any workers.

About Carson Derrow

My name is Carson Derrow I'm an entrepreneur, professional blogger, and marketer from Arkansas. I've been writing for startups and small businesses since 2012. I share the latest business news, tools, resources, and marketing tips to help startups and small businesses to grow their business.


  1. Taxes as an independent contractor are pretty easy to figure out. There’s plenty of tax calculators online designed just for them that are updated annually as the IRS changes the numbers. Paying quarterly is a breeze too with the IRS’s EFTPS site (https://www.eftps.gov/eftps/). Just create an account, attach a checking or savings account to it and pay. There’s only a few pieces of advice I’d give. Be sure to sign up with EFTPS and give yourself some leeway before that first tax payment is due because the IRS mails out your PIN and you’ve got to have that before you can actually make a payment. Know your four quarterly due dates for the IRS payments. You still have to file every year in April too, but if you calculated correctly, you’ll either get a refund or owe just a minute amount. Not much different than when an employer takes taxes out. The first year you won’t need to do quarterly, but every year after that you will if you’re going to owe more than $1,000 in taxes. That’s not $1,000 in earnings, that’s owing more than $1,000 in taxes. That’s it. Super simple and well worth it to be self-employed.

  2. I should also add that every relationship I’ve had as an independent contractor required the signing of an independent contract agreement between the company and myself. If there’s any confusion on the part of the individual on whether they are an employee or an IC, it’s spelled out pretty plainly. Companies are very clear on whether their WAH positions are IC or employee. The IC contracts are pretty basic. They typically outline the performance of the job or the duties expected to be performed, that either party may cancel the contract at any time for any reason, that the IC is not an employee of the company, any benefits provided to the contractor (benefits are rare, but some companies do provide them) and a confidentiality clause about keeping company knowledge that is divulged during the term of the contract private and secret as well as a limitation on an IC using company knowledge after the end of the contract for a year or longer.

  3. Steven J Fromm says

    Readers should be aware that the IRS has increased its audit presence in this area. In addition, they have a new amnesty programs for those taxpayers who have miss-classified employees. I have a you tube discussion at my website and other free articles on this subject both at my website and my blog for those interested in the details of this program.

  4. Fantastic discussion – For my two cents if you need a IRS W-9 , my wife found a fillable version here https://goo.gl/KlbT1F.


  1. […] at Entrepreneurship Life delineates the differences between being an employee, and being an independent contractor. If you […]

  2. […] This version is the right choice for you if you are a sole-proprietor, consultant, 1099 contractor, or single-member LLC.  It is also a good version if you must prepare W-2 or 1099-MISC forms for your employees or contractors. […]

Speak Your Mind

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.